MEMBER ITEMS FOR SALE
Custom Knives | Other Knives | General Items
-------------------------------------------
New Posts | New PhotosAll Photos



Go Back   The Knife Network Forums : Knife Making Discussions > Members List

jimmontg jimmontg is offline

Guru

Visitor Messages

Showing Visitor Messages 1 to 10 of 11
  1. MVPeterson
    03-27-2018 12:43 PM
    MVPeterson
    I just seen a comment/question on one of my pics that you posted a few weeks ago. Tiger coral is the handle material. Fairly easy to work with, porous though, and expensive - only time Iíve used it, but I plan on using it again. Makes a nice looking handle. That knife sold fast. Thanks for the compliments. - Mark
  2. Lee Barnhill
    06-28-2017 07:11 PM
    Lee Barnhill
    Hife Jim
    I didn't notice the comments you made on a knife I put on 6-15. Thanks,and the first thing my wife said when she saw it was You didn't line up the pins!! LOL Where are you moving to in N.M? Lee
  3. samuraistuart
    02-21-2017 11:57 AM
    samuraistuart
    I had typed up a whole thing yesterday, but this stupid PM system limits to 1000 characters and I wasn't in the mood to chop it up and send it in pieces like I had done previously. I'll try to be brief.
    1. Flexibility has nothing to do with hardness....it is determined solely by geometry. Hardness will determine how it fails. 2. You're looking up data for D2 developed for DIES...not edged tools. DO NOT TEMPER BEFORE CRYO!!!! 3. I've seen cryo data for O1 that says 400% increase in wear resistance. NO freaking way does cryo add 400% to wear resistance. WR is built into the steel with it's chemistry. You can't change that with cryo. 4. Sub zero (dry ice) will take care of RA in most steels, but some like the super complex SS need LN2 to get full RA conversion. 5. LN2 allows some super small eta carbide to precip upon tempering, but these carbides aren't about wear resistance, merely added cohesion between the martensite matrix and the primary carbides.
  4. samuraistuart
    02-19-2017 12:49 PM
    samuraistuart
    Part 6...
    Hope you understand, I'm just trying to share knowledge. Not claiming anything. I'm no metallurgist....but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night.
  5. samuraistuart
    02-19-2017 12:49 PM
    samuraistuart
    Part 5...
    With that said, I know it's easy for us to get used to doing it a certain way, and changing something that has been working for us is like fixing something that isn't broken. But if you find that there is no change in your end product by experimenting with different techniques...it may be the techniques aren't actually THAT important to the end product! Which is why, when something works for us, we keep doing it. I started not knowing any of it, asking questions to Kevin and Robert, 2 metallurgists, and reading the literature till my eyes bled, then used those techniques when I started making knives. They work for me, but I thought I would pass it along, anyway.
  6. samuraistuart
    02-19-2017 12:48 PM
    samuraistuart
    Part 4...
    One other thing...you mentioned that you do a temper before cryo/sub zero. I know this has been done in the past, for strictly one reason, concern about distortion in the sub zero/cryo, and the snap temper will help that. However....why are we employing cryo/sub zero? It is to convert retained austenite that didn't get converted to untempered martensite at room temp post quench. What does tempering do, among other things? Stabilizes retained austenite. So if you are tempering BEFORE your sub zero/cryo...you're kinda negating the whole purpose of sub zero/cryo. Sub zero/cryo should ALWAYS be part of a continuous quench. That is to say, blade is at austenitizing temp, quenched down to room temp, then immediately into the dry ice or LN2. Then brought back UP to room temp, then tempered.
  7. samuraistuart
    02-19-2017 12:48 PM
    samuraistuart
    Part 3...
    If it is unprotected from decarb...there will be more decarb. I just don't see any good reason at all to place blades in a cold kiln...and have asked the metallurgists, and they say don't do that. Plus...what about kilns that OVERSHOOT temp when stabilizing at target temp? My kiln doesn't....its 110V and very slow to warm up (glass kiln), never overshoots but I wait anyway before inserting the blade. Guys with evenheats and paragons have often noted that the temp will overshoot big time. You want your blade in there in when it does that? Not me.
  8. samuraistuart
    02-19-2017 12:47 PM
    samuraistuart
    Part 2...
    You may/may not know this...I asked Kevin Cashen and Robert C about the importance of a 1200 pre soak in Hypefree blades some years ago. Their answer...it is not needed in knife sized cross sections. Pre soak is to allow a thick, or complicated, piece of steel to come up to temp evenly. If the steel is heavily alloyed, as in some of the stainless and tool steels out there today, then pre soak at critical, then ramping to the high austenitizing temp is indeed important. For O1 in knives we make....not needed at all. Plus, think about it....that is excess time in the austenite range (1350+). We are after small grain, no? That is time in the austenite phase that "may" grow aus grain. Granted....steels like O1 with the Vanadium and Tungsten probably won't see much of that. But 1095 and the like? I can't imagine what that grain looks like, especially on slow ramping kilns like mine.
  9. samuraistuart
    02-19-2017 12:46 PM
    samuraistuart
    Jim, thanks for your input on the O1 warping thread. The comments I want to make are more directed to you, so would be derailing the thread. I think someone said it best....for this situation...we might have to actually BE THERE to help the guy.

    Anyway...a few things I noticed and wanted to tell you...you mentioned a filet knife in D2 that was flexible. Maybe you know this already, but I just wanted to clarify for you....flexibility has absolutely nothing to do with a steel type or how hard it is. It is simply a matter of geometry. Now, with that said, HOW the piece will FAIL will be determined by hardness, and some extent the steel type. Looks like I have to send this message in pieces....
  10. ben murphy
    08-17-2016 05:59 AM
    ben murphy
    Thanks for the kind message Jim. I will touch base next week when I land. speak then Ben

About Me

  • About jimmontg
    Biography
    Am a high precision welder, tig mostly and also was an sheetmetal guy put out of work by computers. I used to make knives from time to time when I worked as I was the heat treat guy, mostly O-1 and D-2. O-1 is a favorite for it's edge holding ability
    Location
    Now live in Las Cruces NM.
    Interests
    Knifemaking and leather work.
    Occupation
    I am retired now, but make a knife from time to time. Some from O-1 and some from TKS.
    Real Name
    Jimmie
  • Signature
    Now it says Guru and it used to say Master. I think I like Master better, though skilled would be the best description

Statistics

Total Posts
Albums
Visitor Messages
General Information
  • Last Activity: 02-20-2020 09:49 PM
  • Join Date: 01-30-2016

Friends

Showing Friends 1 to 3 of 3

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:29 AM.




KNIFENETWORK.COM
Copyright © 2000
? CKK Industries, Inc. ? All Rights Reserved
Powered by ...

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
The Knife Network : All Rights Reserved